Op-Eds Opinion

SHOVE IT RIGHT UP YOUR…: A MESSAGE TO THE US JUDGE WHO ISSUED THE SUMMONS TO AJIT DOVAL

America may be accustomed to throwing its weight around the world, but India is not Washington’s subordinate, and American judicial paperwork does not come with a licence to trample Indian sovereignty.

There is something spectacularly irritating about the American establishment’s enduring conviction that the rest of the world is obliged to dance whenever Washington snaps its fingers. Whether it is the White House delivering sermons on democracy, the State Department distributing certificates of acceptable behaviour, or American institutions exercising their authority beyond US borders, the underlying attitude too often appears remarkably similar. America speaks, and everybody else is expected to listen.

Now comes another controversy involving India’s National Security Adviser Ajit Doval, former Research and Analysis Wing chief Samant Goel, and a civil lawsuit filed in New York by Khalistani separatist Gurpatwant Singh Pannun. An American federal judge has authorised the transmission of summonses through Indian courts, placing two senior Indian security figures at the centre of proceedings initiated thousands of kilometres away.

The legal process itself deserves accurate explanation. The summons is not a conviction, and the American judge has requested assistance under provisions of international and Indian law. But the larger spectacle raises a question that Washington’s establishment has rarely appeared comfortable answering. Where exactly does American authority end, and when will the United States learn that being powerful does not make it everybody else’s superior?

As for the summons involving Ajit Doval, we have a suggestion for the American judicial establishment. It is short, exceptionally impolite, and already appears in the headline.

The Khalistani Separatist Behind the American Lawsuit

The controversy begins with Gurpatwant Singh Pannun, a US citizen and prominent advocate of the separatist Khalistan movement. Pannun is associated with Sikhs for Justice, an organisation banned by the Government of India. In July 2020, India formally designated him an individual terrorist under the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act.

These distinctions matter. Pannun’s political activities are viewed very differently by the two countries. His citizenship and legal protections in America do not erase India’s national-security concerns, just as India’s designation does not automatically extinguish his legal rights under American law.

In November 2023, US prosecutors announced charges involving an alleged conspiracy to assassinate Pannun in New York. Indian national Nikhil Gupta was accused of participating in the murder-for-hire plot alongside an individual described by prosecutors as an Indian government employee. In October 2024, American authorities charged Vikash Yadav in connection with the case.

The criminal proceedings subsequently produced a significant development. On February 13, 2026, Gupta pleaded guilty to murder-for-hire, conspiracy to commit murder-for-hire and conspiracy to commit money laundering.

That guilty plea is a fact, not something to be brushed aside simply because the case involves India. Neither does it establish that Ajit Doval or Samant Goel authorised the conspiracy. Criminal responsibility is not contagious, and the guilt of one individual cannot be casually transferred to every prominent official whom a plaintiff chooses to name.

Pannun separately filed a civil lawsuit in September 2024, naming the Government of India, Doval, Goel and others as defendants. The suit seeks to establish responsibility for the alleged conspiracy. Those civil allegations against Doval and Goel remain unproven.

On November 9, 2026, US District Judge Katherine Polk Failla authorised an alternative procedure for serving the two Indian officials through courts in Delhi. A subsequent order dated November 17 directed the transmission of judicial documents to the relevant Indian courts, including Patiala House, Dwarka and Tis Hazari.

Thus, an American civil lawsuit brought by a Khalistani separatist has generated an international judicial request involving some of India’s most senior national-security figures.

And Washington should not be surprised that this has provoked an angry response.

India Has Already Rejected the Allegations. Was That Not Clear Enough?

On November 10, India’s Ministry of External Affairs rejected the accusations directed against its senior officials. Spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal described the attacks as fabricated and malicious, dismissed the lawsuits as frivolous, and stressed that requests to serve judicial documents in India must pass through the designated central authority, the Ministry of Law and Justice.

That was a clear statement of the Indian government’s position. The allegations against Doval and Goel were rejected, and India asserted the importance of its own legal procedures.

The subsequent American court order relies on provisions of the Hague Service Convention and India’s Code of Civil Procedure. It formally requests assistance from Indian courts. There is an established legal framework through which foreign judicial documents may be served, and India has laws governing precisely such cooperation.

But a procedure for delivering a summons must not be confused with a foreign court acquiring unlimited authority over the Republic of India. Serving a document is one question. Establishing jurisdiction, overcoming objections, determining liability and enforcing any eventual judgment are quite different questions.

Washington’s institutions would do well to remember that distinction before anyone mistakes American judicial paperwork for an international commandment.

India is not required to treat an accusation as established truth merely because somebody filed it in New York. Nor should the prominence of the American legal system somehow elevate the plaintiff’s claims above the normal requirements of evidence and due process.

A lawsuit is not a coronation. A summons is not a sentence. And an American courtroom is not the Supreme Court of Planet Earth.

Who the Hell Appointed America the World’s Policeman?

The United States has cultivated an extraordinary habit of inserting itself into the political, economic and security affairs of other nations while behaving as though its interventions are a public service for which humanity ought to express gratitude.

Washington has spent decades lecturing countries about sovereignty, restraint, international law and respect for institutions. Yet the same Washington has repeatedly claimed sweeping freedom to pursue its interests beyond its own borders.

Consider Iraq. In 2003, the United States invaded a sovereign country amid claims about weapons of mass destruction that were subsequently discredited. An American Senate intelligence investigation found that major pre-war intelligence assessments had been overstated or lacked sufficient supporting evidence.

A catastrophic foreign-policy decision was made, an entire region suffered the consequences, and the American establishment eventually moved on to its next international lecture.

Where was the legendary American humility then?

Or consider Washington’s extensive use of economic sanctions, including measures affecting foreign businesses and individuals dealing with countries targeted by US policy. The message is frequently unmistakable. Accept the priorities of the United States or risk consequences, even when your own country has adopted a different position.

Apparently, sovereignty is a magnificent principle when America invokes it and an inconvenient technicality when somebody else does.

This is the obnoxious feature of American exceptionalism. Washington treats its national interests as sacred, its security calculations as uniquely sophisticated and its institutional preferences as standards that other nations should aspire to obey.

Everybody else, meanwhile, must submit explanations, demonstrate good behaviour and hope the self-appointed examiner in Washington is satisfied.

The arrogance would almost be entertaining if its consequences were not so serious.

American Exceptionalism Is Not International Law

There is nothing objectionable about America protecting its citizens from criminal violence. An alleged assassination conspiracy on American soil is plainly a matter its authorities have reason to investigate. India would similarly insist on investigating a comparable crime within its jurisdiction.

What deserves criticism is the wider habit of presenting American interests and institutions as though they occupy a higher plane of legitimacy than those of other sovereign countries.

The United States has conducted intelligence operations abroad, pursued suspected enemies across borders, imposed unilateral sanctions and justified extraordinary national-security measures by citing the dangers confronting its own citizens.

Yet when other countries invoke national security, Washington’s political establishment is often eager to assume the position of international moral supervisor.

That double standard deserves relentless scrutiny.

The answer is not that every security operation undertaken by another country should be excused. Nor is it that murder-for-hire becomes acceptable when somebody invokes patriotism. Such an argument would be as indefensible for India as it would be for America.

The answer is that international law and accountability must not become instruments of selective political convenience.

Washington cannot demand universal reverence for American sovereignty while treating the sovereignty of others as negotiable.

And India has every reason to reject the humiliating proposition that the American interpretation of every international controversy must automatically prevail.

Ajit Doval Is India’s National Security Adviser, Not Washington’s Employee

Ajit Doval serves the Republic of India. He does not work for the United States, report to the State Department or hold his position at the pleasure of an American judicial establishment.

He is a senior official of a sovereign government, and allegations against him must be evaluated through applicable law, proper evidence and the relevant jurisdictional rules.

That is not an argument for immunity from every conceivable legal proceeding. It is an argument against the presumption that naming an Indian official in an American lawsuit is sufficient to resolve every question of accountability.

Any immunity claim, jurisdictional objection or procedural dispute must be assessed according to law. India is entitled to advance its position, defend its officials and insist that its legal institutions receive the respect due to them.

The United States does not get to replace that process with its preferred outcome simply because it possesses considerable global influence.

The irritation surrounding this controversy is therefore not merely about a sheet of paper travelling from New York to Delhi. It concerns the political symbolism of an American legal process involving India’s national-security leadership at the initiative of a separatist whom India has formally designated a terrorist.

That distinction is precisely why New Delhi’s response matters.

India does not need lessons in national security from a country whose own history contains enough questionable interventions, intelligence controversies and spectacular strategic miscalculations to fill several libraries.

Washington may have an enormous defence budget, powerful intelligence agencies and formidable legal institutions. None of those things confers moral infallibility.

And none transforms India’s National Security Adviser into an American subordinate.

India Is an American Partner, Not an American Protectorate

Perhaps the most irritating feature of Washington’s behaviour is the persistent confusion between partnership and obedience.

India and the United States maintain important relationships in defence, intelligence, technology, trade and regional security. Those relationships are built on shared interests, not on India’s surrender of its sovereign judgment.

America does not get to become India’s commanding officer simply because the two countries cooperate. It cannot expect New Delhi to endorse every American foreign-policy priority, accept every Washington interpretation of events or treat every American institutional demand as an instruction from a superior authority.

India is not a protectorate. It is not a dependent territory. It is certainly not some obedient little outpost of American geopolitical ambition.

The Republic of India has its own Constitution, its own judiciary, its own national-security institutions and its own obligations under international law. They are not decorative arrangements awaiting approval from Washington.

One might reasonably ask whether the American establishment has ever considered the possibility that other nations take their sovereignty just as seriously as Americans take theirs.

Apparently, that thought remains difficult to accommodate.

There is a reason genuine international partnerships require reciprocity. Mutual respect cannot be a one-way transaction in which Washington makes demands while everybody else demonstrates gratitude for the privilege of receiving them.

If the United States wants India as a serious strategic partner, it must accept India as an independent power capable of disagreement, resistance and the defence of its own interests.

Anything less is not partnership. It is arrogance wearing a diplomatic necktie.

Your Honour, India Doesn’t Take Orders From Washington

Which brings us back to Judge Katherine Polk Failla and the summonses involving Ajit Doval and Samant Goel.

The American court has issued an order seeking judicial assistance through Indian legal procedures. The Indian government has already rejected the underlying allegations against its officials. The relevant legal questions must be addressed through the applicable judicial processes, not through an assumption that Washington’s wishes automatically become India’s obligations.

But beyond those procedural details lies a much larger message that needs to be delivered with exceptional clarity.

The United States is not the owner of the international order. Its courts are not the final arbiters of every dispute involving foreign governments. Its political establishment is not humanity’s collective guardian, and its enormous military power does not entitle it to an unlimited supply of international deference.

America is one country among many. A powerful country, certainly. An influential country, undoubtedly. But still a country, not an emperor with a collection of subordinate nations.

Washington seems remarkably fond of preaching respect for institutions. Perhaps it could begin by remembering that institutions outside the United States exist too.

India is not required to behave like a nervous schoolchild summoned to the headmaster’s office every time an American institution produces another document.

And the sooner Washington abandons that insufferable attitude, the sooner it might discover the difference between being respected and simply being powerful.

As for the summons, Your Honour, you are perfectly entitled to exercise the powers granted to your court under American law. India is equally entitled to insist on its sovereignty, its legal procedures and the rights of its officials.

But if anyone in Washington imagines that a summons comes with an unquestionable right to command the Republic of India, we have a rather direct response.

Shove it right up your…

We trust the American establishment is sufficiently imaginative to complete the sentence without requiring assistance from an Indian court.

Related Posts