X Plans Appeal After Karnataka HC Orders Takedown Compliance
Social media platform X (formerly Twitter) has announced it will appeal a recent Karnataka High Court ruling that requires the company to comply with government-issued takedown notices. The firm called the order “deeply concerning,” warning that it could empower millions of police officers to issue removal orders without oversight.
Court Upholds Sahyog Portal And Government Powers
The High Court dismissed X’s petitions challenging the legal validity of the government’s content removal mechanism. The court held that social media firms must obey Indian laws and cannot apply U.S.-style free speech arguments to Indian context. The judgment also emphasized that constitutional protections for free speech apply to Indian citizens, not foreign platforms.
X’s Concerns Over Free Expression
X says the Sahyog portal, used by police and state agencies to issue takedown orders, permits content removal requests based solely on allegations of illegality. The company argues the system lacks judicial review, procedural safeguards, and could impose criminal liability for non-compliance.
Next Steps And Wider Stakes
X aims to challenge the ruling in higher courts. The case reflects a broader clash over India’s expanding internet oversight and how free speech is regulated online. Pressure is growing on platforms to balance compliance with government rules and protecting user rights.
