SC Rejects Plea Over Screening ‘Thug Life’ in Karnataka
The Supreme Court has refused to entertain a petition seeking protection for theatres intending to screen the Tamil film Thug Life in Karnataka. The court cited serious concerns over law and order, including clear threats of arson, and directed the petitioners to approach the Karnataka High Court instead.
A bench comprising Justices Prashant Kumar Mishra and Manmohan heard the plea filed under Article 32 by the Karnataka Theatre Association. The association had requested urgent directions to ensure safe and uninterrupted screening of the film, which is embroiled in a linguistic and political controversy. The court, however, stated that it was not the appropriate forum at this stage and advised the petitioners to seek remedy from the state judiciary.
“Install Fire Extinguishers,” Says Court
In a pointed response to requests for preventive protection, one of the judges remarked, “Install fire extinguishers,” highlighting the seriousness of the threats received by cinema halls. The comment underscored the court’s position that the matter involves public order issues better handled locally, rather than through central intervention.
The decision effectively leaves theatre owners in Karnataka without central legal protection, placing the responsibility on state authorities to manage security and legal grievances.
Film Caught in Language Controversy
The controversy began after Thug Life actor Kamal Haasan made remarks during the film’s audio launch suggesting that the Kannada language was derived from Tamil. This statement sparked outrage among Kannada groups, who called for a ban on the film and accused Haasan of disrespecting their linguistic identity.
As tensions grew, the Karnataka Film Chamber of Commerce decided to withhold permission for the movie’s release in the state. This led to the current legal battle, as theatre owners faced threats of violence should they proceed with screening the film.
Thug Life was released on June 5 in Tamil, Telugu, Malayalam, and Hindi, but remains unavailable in Karnataka.
