Justice Kant Says Countries with Poor Records Criticise India
Supreme Court judge Surya Kant, who will soon become India’s Chief Justice, has highlighted that some countries with strict immigration laws and histories of excessive force often criticise India’s human rights record. Speaking in Sweden, he called this stance “paradoxical” and urged for more self-reflection in global discussions on rights.
India’s Strong Human Rights Foundations
Justice Kant praised India’s long history of human rights protection, rooted in its constitution and ancient traditions. He said that India’s commitment predates global conventions and reflects its civilisational values of dignity and compassion.
Critique of Double Standards
He pointed out that countries justifying harsh immigration measures and forceful policing shouldn’t position themselves as human rights champions without introspection. He compared this to expecting uniform coffee cultures, emphasizing that each country’s legal and cultural context must be understood.
Arbitration and Rule of Law
During the event, Justice Kant also promoted India as a fair and affordable place for international arbitration. He said India’s independent judiciary and investor-protection mechanisms make it a reliable choice for foreign firms seeking legal recourse.
Acknowledged Human Rights Challenges
While defending India, Justice Kant did not deny its challenges. He acknowledged issues like custodial violence and urged continued reforms. Data shows that India has recorded numerous custodial deaths in recent years—an area he said must be addressed to strengthen trust in its legal system.
Call for Mutual Respect
Justice Kant concluded by calling for global human rights conversations that respect diverse legal traditions. He stressed that progress depends not on imposing a single model, but on mutual understanding and allowing nations to grow based on their histories and social frameworks.
